One of the earliest decisions in a golf simulator build is whether to use a net or an impact screen. This choice affects space requirements, cost, safety, noise, and how immersive the simulator feels. There is no universally better option. The right setup depends on your room, your budget, and how you plan to use the simulator.
This guide compares nets vs impact screens in real UK home and commercial spaces. It supports the full planning process outlined here: How to Build a Golf Simulator in the UK (Complete Guide 2026).
Start with space, not preference
Most people start with what they want the simulator to look like. The better approach is starting with what the room allows.
- Depth determines whether an impact screen is practical.
- Width affects centre vs offset hitting.
- Height influences swing comfort and projector placement.
If you are still measuring, read: Golf Simulator Room Size Guide (UK).
What a net setup does well
A net setup focuses on practice and ball capture. It is the simplest and most flexible way to start hitting real shots indoors.
Advantages of a net
- Works in shallower rooms
- Lower upfront cost
- Quick to install and remove
- Less concern about projector alignment
Limitations of a net
- No projected image on impact
- Less immersive for on-course play
- Visual feedback relies on a separate screen or device
Nets suit garages, spare rooms, and shared spaces where flexibility matters. A good example is a freestanding practice net like the SimSpace Deluxe Golf Practice Net, which works well in tight spaces.
What an impact screen does well
An impact screen transforms the simulator from a practice station into a full golf experience. It allows projected visuals, multiplayer rounds, and social play.
Advantages of an impact screen
- Immersive on-course experience
- Clear visual feedback at impact
- Better for guests and group play
- Feels closer to a commercial simulator bay
Limitations of an impact screen
- Requires more depth
- Higher cost once projector and mounting are included
- Needs careful tensioning to control bounce-back
Impact screens suit dedicated rooms, garden rooms, and finished garages. Popular options include premium materials like the SimSpace Platinum Impact Screen for reduced bounce-back and better image quality.
Depth requirements compared
Depth is usually the deciding factor.
Net depth guidance
- Can work from around 3.5 to 4.0 m total room depth
- Ball-to-net distance can be shorter
- More forgiving in tight spaces
Impact screen depth guidance
- Typically needs 4.6 to 5.5 m total depth
- Ball-to-screen distance around 2.5 to 3.6 m
- Extra space behind the player improves comfort
Exact numbers vary with screen quality and setup. Always measure at the tightest point.
Safety considerations
Both setups can be safe when done properly. The risks are different.
Net safety
- Excellent at stopping the ball
- Side misses still need protection
- Lower rebound risk
Impact screen safety
- Requires correct distance and tension
- Side protection is essential
- Bounce-back needs managing
For a deeper dive, read: Golf Simulator Safety: Screen Distance & Side Protection.
Noise and comfort
Nets tend to be quieter because they absorb energy without a flat rebound surface. Impact screens can be louder, especially in hard rooms, but improve significantly with proper tension and side curtains.
Noise control ties into: Golf Simulator Lighting & Finish.
Cost comparison
Typical net setup costs (UK)
- Net and frame: lower cost
- No projector required
- Ideal for starter builds
Typical impact screen setup costs (UK)
- Impact screen and frame or enclosure
- Projector and mounting
- Higher overall investment
For full budgeting context, see: Golf Simulator Build Costs (UK).
Hybrid approaches
Some builds start with a net and later upgrade to a screen. Others use a net behind a retractable screen. These approaches can work if planned early.
If you expect to upgrade later, choose components that will not need replacing. Starting with quality screens or enclosures avoids double spending.
Which setup should you choose?
- Choose a net if depth is limited, budget is tight, or practice is the priority.
- Choose an impact screen if you want immersion, social play, and a finished look.
Many golfers start with a net and move to a screen once they know how they use the simulator.
Shop both options here: Enclosures and Projectors.
Seeing the difference in person
The feel of a net versus an impact screen is hard to judge online. Seeing ball flight, rebound behaviour, and how much space feels comfortable makes the decision clearer.
This is especially helpful if your room is borderline on depth.
